Recent Posts
Recent Comments
Meta |
Weekly Recon, 5/28/08
May 26th, 2008
by Katherine Dacey
I, Otaku: Struggle in Akihabara, Vol. 2 (Seven Seas): As one might guess from the title, I, Otaku is a meta-manga about fandom in all its various permutations: anime fanatics, figurine collectors, fujoshi. Though the slapstick and obsessive behavior need no editorial intervention to comprehend, the dialogue is peppered with references to singers, actors, and other figures in the Japanese public eye. Not to worry—translator/adaptor Ed “MangaCast” Chavez has provided copious notes to let the uninitiated in on the jokes. At last year’s New York Anime Fest, Ed assured me that volume two will be even funnier than volume one as Sota and Kenji take a gig at a magazine called Boys’ Heaven. Sounds like a perfect chaser for the first two installments of Fujoshi Rumi (Media Blasters) to me. My Heavenly Hockey Club, Vol. 5 (Del Rey): Saying My Heavenly Hockey Club isn’t my favorite Ai Morinaga title is a bit like saying Great Expectations isn’t my favorite David Lean movie—it’s still a fun series, even if it isn’t quite on par with her best work. My chief criticism of Hockey Club is its repetitiousness: midway through volume one, Morinaga fell into a predictable routine of road trips, forfeited games, and wacky hijinks, even as she sent her team of misfits to increasingly exotic locations. Still, the artwork is a big step up from Duck Prince and Your and My Secret, and Morinaga’s try-anything-for-a-laugh approach hits the bull’s eye more often than not—though I’m wondering if she’s jumped the The Palette of 12 Secret Colors, Vol. 3 (CMX): Thanks to routine abuse by Gene Shalit and Michael Medved, words like “gentle,” “sweet,” and “charming” pack all the critical punch of “nice” and “good.” Yet this all-ages adventure story about a female palette (i.e., magician who manipulates color) is gentle, sweet, and charming without being twee or preachy. True, Palette would have been more effective in color—a point manga-ka Nari Kusakawa freely concedes—but the stylish art and appealing cast help offset this obvious limitation of the storytelling. Highly recommended whether you’re a shojo fanatic, a shonen junkie, or a parent in search of an all-ages title that will entertain your tween without offending your sensibilities. HEY, BIG SPENDER… Have a money-saving tip you’d like to share with other manga maniacs? Send me an email and I’ll post it in a future edition of the Weekly Recon. SHIPPING THIS WEEK |




Another short shipping list, another week of solvency… My top picks for this week:
Leave a Comment
Trackback this post | Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed