MORE REVIEWS > view archive
FRESH PREVIEWS > view archive
LATEST HEADLINES > view archive
|
Weekly Recon, 5/14/08
May 12th, 2008
by Katherine Dacey
Bookmark this post
My top picks for Wednesday: Blood+, Vol. 2 (Dark Horse): This brooding vampire tale adopts a kitchen-sink approach to plotting, mixing military conspiracy theory with teen angst and a healthy dose of monster-slaying. The results are oddly compelling; if anything, Blood+ demonstrates that it’s entirely possible to fashion something new and exciting out of shopworn ideas. If you’re a fan of the anime, you’ll notice a few discrepancies between the manga and the TV show. The biggest difference is Saya herself. As depicted in the manga, Saya is feisty, loyal, and only a little hesitant to embrace her destiny as a human weapon—a big improvement over her shrill, conflicted persona in the anime. Shoulder-A-Coffin, Kuro, Vol. 1 (Yen Press): The story is a take-it-or-leave-it proposition; some may find the art too cutesy for the rather serious subject, while others may find the story ill-suited to the set-up/punchline rhythms of 4-koma format. For the otaku in search of an offbeat read, however, Kuro offers a unique and satisfying blend of humor, whimsy, and melancholy. Toto! The Wonderful Adventure, Vol. 1 (Del Rey): Yuko Osada’s boisterous romp reads like a mash-up of One Piece and Castle in the Sky, complete with a flying ship, a cute animal sidekick, a spunky heroine, and a band of pirates on the run from the authorities. The artwork has a loose, sketchy feel that nicely complements Toto’s breezy tone. And while the story is positively elemental when compared with many shonen series, its simplicity allows Osada to focus more on characters and plot and less on superpowers and backstory—a decided plus. Ultimate Venus, Vol. 1 (Go! Comi): Like Ai Morinaga, Takako Shigematsu has a knack for spicing up a stock shojo premise—say, a showbiz melodrama—with liberal amounts of black humor and sexual tension. In Ultimate Venus, Shigematsu’s point of departure is the My Fair Lady makeover, in which a handsome Henry Higgins surrogate teaches a klutzy young woman how to comport herself among the rich and famous. Or in this case, two hot linguists teach a klutzy young woman how to talk and walk like a lady. Eliza Doolittle should be so lucky! Yakitate!! Japan, Vol. 11 (Viz): Every volume of Yakitate!! Japan doggedly adheres to the same basic recipe: one part competition, one part risqué humor, one part yeasty puns, and one part wacky hijinks. Kazuma Azuma and the Pantasia gang are always the underdogs at a world-renown bread-baking tournament, only to pull off a stunning victory on the strength of one of Kazuma’s more outlandish creations—but not before a new, ridiculous opponent (often in a mask or outré costume) announces his intent to outbake them. All of this amounts to predictably good fun, even if the fanservice gets a little out of hand at times. Haven’t tried Yakitate!! yet? Read the first two volumes, then sample at will—you won’t have difficulty figuring out what’s happening. One final note: from now until May 18th, RightStuf is running a promotion on current and future Tokyopop manga, novels, and tie-in products (i.e. The Fruits Basket Sticker Book). Books are 33% off the cover price; click here for the coupon code. Full shipping list after the cut. SHIPPING THIS WEEK Filed under: Reviews, Blogs, Manga Reviews, Manga Recon, Dark Horse, Del Rey, Go!Comi, Viz, Weekly Recon, Yen Press See Also:
|






If you’re still solvent after last week’s tsunami of new manga, this week may send you straight for bankruptcy court, with dozens of great books headed your way. The list cants heavily towards continuing series like Basara (Viz), Flame of Recca (Viz), Samurai Deeper Kyo (Tokyopop) Sgt. Frog (Tokyopop) and Tsubasa: Reservoir Chronicles (Del Rey), but also features such noteworthy newcomers as Kamisama Kozuko (Go! Comi) and Toto! The Wonderful Adventure (Del Rey).
4 Comments Add your own
1. Ken Haley | May 15th, 2008 at 4:27 pm
Parasyte vol. 3 for me! It kind of caught me by surprise too, it wasn’t on the new arrivals list my LCS sent out. Glad I checked though, they only had one volume in. Yikes.
2. Katherine Dacey | May 15th, 2008 at 6:01 pm
I have Parasyte on my to-read list on the strength of your recommendation, Ken–I just have to work my way through that backlog of review material first! (By then the fourth volume should be available… )
3. mack | May 16th, 2008 at 10:30 pm
I am going to have to go through a Recon in depth one of these days. But for now, I am back to doing the “Scoop”. Short edition on TP and a longer edition in a forum on LoS.
I saw in my very quick surf of the anime sites that Toto was like a spiced up Wizard of Oz. From your review (yes I actually read it) it sound like something I would want to avoid. I mean I don’t really like One Piece.
4. Katherine Dacey | May 17th, 2008 at 11:09 am
Hey Mack–nice to hear from you! Glad to hear “The Scoop” is back.
I really liked Toto!, but it’s not going to be everyone’s cup of tea, especially if you’re not a big fan of shonen heroes who are dreamy, impetuous, and not super-smart. (Kakashi, the hero of Toto!, won’t be winning the Nobel Prize in Economics anytime soon.) The Wizard of Oz references are there, but it’s not a retelling of Frank L. Baum’s story per se. If anything, it reminded me more of a Miyazaki movie than anything, with its colorful cast of pirates, its flying ships, and its spunky heroine.
Leave a Comment
Trackback this post | Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed