PopCultureShock > PCS Comics >

Recommendable – June Initial Thoughts (Maxx, Madame Xanadu)

Posted by: Sirui Huang on June 29, 2009 at 4:44 pm

Thank you for the recommendations and the warm wishes! I am feeling better, and still drinking lots of fluids. I have been somewhat limited in my reading choices, currently quarantined in the suburbs, but I am totally doing my homework. I started with the alternative titles: The Maxx, Madame Xanadu, and Preacher. Some initial thoughts about M. titles:

maxxThe Maxx Vol. 1 – Sam Kieth, with Bill Messner-Loebs on Dialogue
The most impressive part of the Maxx is its raw creativity. There is Maxx, bum, superhero, purple elephant in the panel. There’s Julie, smoking hot and volatile; Mr. Gone, often naked and a bit of a murder-rapist; Is(es), ink-black Pacmen with arms and legs and teeth. The story phases in and out of their subconscious, which so happens to be located in the Australian outback, while their bodies are located in New York. Super creative, and super much going on. I barely remember watching the animated shorts on MTV, and maybe it’s nostalgia goggles at work, but man, they were a hell of a lot easier to watch than to read.
Amazingly, the complexity works. I mean, the world can’t be a simple place when you’re a giant purple delusion. The comic shows a flippant attitude towards convention or compliancy by complicating everything, visually and verbally—and actually manages to be very poignant, very intense, and very funny. The downside is that it is hard to be on all the time. There is no ease in reading, and the overload of images, voices, and ideas is exhausting, and at its worst, pretentious. When everything is ironic or sarcastic, it loses a little heart. While I remain committed to the adventures, I hope that in the next few books Kieth can temper his cleverness, and focus more on the story over the storytelling.
15% OFF The Maxx at MidtownComics.com!

1zbqoubMadame Xanadu – Matt Wagner, Amy Hadley
I read through three issues of Madame Xanadu (Vol. 2) rather hastily I must admit, but in my brief interactions, I found the title really muted. The book meanders about in DC’s mystical realms, following sorceress Nimune in earlier days—but so little happened of concern that I would have trouble summarize the plot. Hadley’s art offers a lot of pretty things to look at, including a fetching protagonist, and Wagner’s writing is careful and poetic. Unfortunately, such flourishes do not produce narrative excitement, but hinders it. The delicate art and the period manner of speech make more obvious the lulls in action and confrontation. I do recognize that some stories need to be told with at a measured pacing, to build a more epic experience (I’m thinking Stracynski’s Thor). But Madame Xanadu hasn’t offer quite enough, not with its characters, or its mythos (especially after it moved out of Camelot) to justify the inaction, and I will be reluctant to continue reading.
15% OFF Madame Xanadu at MidtownComics.com!

I’ll be editing down some initial thoughts on Preacher, and getting ready to head back up to the city. It has been a challenge taking the books in to write about them, and I’d love to hear any comments and objections to my thought. So keep the feedback alive, kids! I will be back here raving about Preacher in a day or two.

del.icio.us Digg Facebook Technorati StumbleUpon TwitThis Yahoo! Buzz
Avatar

KingofBing71 July 4th, 2009

The Maxx, in my opinion, was the peak of Image’s effectiveness in writing. Recently they’ve been juicing themselves back up with titles like Chew and the Rebirth of Spawn. A lot of the non-Marvel/DC titles are starting to peak my interest. I use to be strictly a Marvel guy with a toss-in of TMNT and Maxx in there. The four issue mini-series from IDW called Ghostbusters: The Other Side was very well done. Very true to the movies, although they stopped making GB books after the mini-series. Oh well, cest la vie.

Avatar

Sirui July 7th, 2009

My experience growing up with Image was mostly boobs. Not that it’s a bad thing, but it’s looking like they’re working on shaking that whole TnA branding. No pun intended of course.



Also Check These Out!
Latest from PCS COMICS