10 Jul, 2006

Read This Way: Mangaka Mystique

By: Tania Del Rio

First off, for those of you who regularly read this column, let me apologize for the fact that this month’s column is late. As it turns out, I just got married last week and I have to admit that more than one of my professional obligations was somewhat neglected in the wedding whirlwind.

Now that that’s out of the way, I’m looking forward to San Diego Comic Con, which is coming up real soon. I’ve never been before. I’ll be going purely as a fan—no being chained to a table for me! I want to see lots of things, meet lots of people, and hopefully do it without spending too much money.

I’ll also be curious to see how the manga/anime scene will be at the con. I know TOKYOPOP and Viz will probably have a strong presence as always, but I’m also curious about the smaller companies—and about any individual aspiring manga artists that may be in Artists’ Alley.

I always enjoy meeting creators of American manga. Not only did I get to work with ten of them while putting together Mangaka America (coming out this November!), but I have befriended a number of young Western manga artists thought the Internet as well.

In fact, this has made me think about some of the cultural differences that exist between Japan and the West. In Japan, manga artists are celebrities, maybe even superstars. They are respected and, in some cases, revered. Japanese mangaka also have a reputation for being rather secretive and elusive. It seems that many of them are reluctant to do interviews or even show their faces at all. This surely adds to their mysterious charm and I’m sure some of it has to do with Japanese reluctance to place the individual beneath a spotlight. But I have to admit that I am often frustrated by Japanese creators and their secretive, coy ways.

Every time I read an interview with a Japanese mangaka I feel like they are holding back—giving polite answers and speaking only from the surface. I crave to know more about them: What makes them tick? How did they develop their style? Where do their ideas really come from? What are their lives like? But it is rare that I read an interview that gives me a glimpse into the things I really want to know.

Sometimes I wonder if it’s just a translation thing. Perhaps the English language has butchered and concealed all the intricate nuances and secret thoughts of the interviewee. Maybe only a Japanese person can read an interview and really understand what it is that is being said below the surface!

But then again, maybe it’s not like that at all and Japanese mangaka are just plain secretive—or actually are boring individuals with not a lot to say. Who knows? All I can say that in America, it’s different. Here, our young manga artists are certainly basking within the glow of their respective fan bases, and seem more than happy to connect with their readers. And while they have a ways to go before they reach superstar status, I have no doubt that, down the line, they will become as well known and admired as many Japanese mangaka.

In fact, I think it may happen sooner than it would in Japan simply because Western creators are so willing to share themselves with their fans. Very few American manga artists are secretive and elusive. Most of them seem perfectly happy and willing to blog frequently, giving fans an intimate glimpse into their personal lives and thoughts. They attend conventions and events regularly; they volunteer to teach classes at libraries. They form actual friendships with their fans; they debate with them. They share their work, their thought processes, and accept criticism (some better than others).

The point is, my belief is that this openness will propel these artists’ careers and help them reach new heights. Of course, it could also be argued that some secrecy is also a good thing. Not only for the artists who may regret what they blog in front of hundreds of fans, but for the fans as well. I’m sure I’m not the only one who has idolized someone only to be disappointed upon finally meeting them. After all, we’re only human, and realizing that someone that you have looked up to is just an average person with faults can be somewhat disenchanting.

Despite that, I think I’d still prefer to know an artist as a person, faults and all. I also wonder if part of Western mangaka’s openness is due to their age. Many of the emerging American mangaka are under thirty years old and, therefore, are about as old as their fans. So it would seem natural that friendships would form more easily between the creators and their readers—no doubt they have a lot in common. Conventions aren’t just a place to line up and meet young creators, but to hang out with them too. In return, the creators are active on various Web sites and message boards providing advice, critiques, and support to aspiring artists. I think this kind of rapport is wonderful and I hope it continues even as the creators become more and more famous.

A notable downside to this back-and-forth conversation is that the Internet is a breeding ground for misinterpretation. Tempers often flare and feelings can be easily hurt when someone says exactly what they think of someone’s art. I realized, when I first started a blog and became more vocal on the Web, that not all the people I communicated with would be nice. And I have, indeed, been on the end of spiteful criticism or strange requests from various people I will probably never meet. But even though it may be tempting at times to retreat into obscurity, where I’m protected from harsh opinions, I won’t. Because I really believe that to create loyal fans, you have to treat them with the same respect they treat you. It works both ways. And, hey, I’ve made some good friends along the way as well.

Categories/Tags: Columns, Read This Way,

7 Responses to "Read This Way: Mangaka Mystique"

1 | djFRiTZ

October 28th, 2006 at 6:33 pm

Avatar

Hi
I need a talented ANIME artist to do a few illustrations for a proposal to a MAJOR Japanese entertainment company.
Style: akira, ghost in the shell etc.
there is payment $$$.
professional full color images– two week deadline

please leave website and contact info: Fritzo131@aol.com

Reply - Fritzo131@aol.com‘); return false;”>Quote

2 | Madison

February 27th, 2007 at 10:27 am

Avatar

I’m writing a research paper about how American mangaka are often frowned upon. I have a few ideas why, but I fear it won’t be enough. Anyone else have any opinions as to why we are hated so?

lol…sob…

3 | danae harrington

June 3rd, 2007 at 7:19 pm

Avatar

American Manga-ka’s are “hated” because anime is seen as an art form in the Japanese culture, buuuut since Americans are not Japanese they are “imposters” They are imposing on this art form that has been held exclusivly for the Japanese for so long. In my personal opinion it is just another branch of being Bias. Who is to say that an American cant make a manga as well as a Japanese person? My personal goal is to become a manga-ka in Japan under an Alias and if my series gets popular i will reveal that i am American. I belive that that move will help spur the movement against Bais artforms. Offer your support and send me some luck as i have a meeting with the American editor of Furuba July 10th (Lillian Diaz) to talk about that very idea.

4 | Kevin P.

October 18th, 2007 at 8:39 pm

Avatar

I find it interesting to see how aggressively the Japanese community maintains “their style” of animation/comic art as completely original. It’s especially ironic to note that the manga/anime styles were inspired by Disney’s original animations. True that ancient Oriental art had an undeniable impact on Japanese comics and animation techniques, but when you take a look at some of the older, traditional styles of manga/anime such as witnessed in Astro Boy, it can be noted that there is a very similar feel to more Western-style animations. The Japanese certainly have a unique style of art to call their own, but it’s undeniable how much of an impact the Western world has had on it.

5 | Andrew C.

October 21st, 2007 at 3:28 am

Avatar

Hmmm, in my opinion, American Mangaka may be “hated” because thier mangas usually don’t reflect much of Japanese culture. To produce a manga (even if you are no Japanese), you have to understand Japanese culture.

6 | kiyomi

January 30th, 2008 at 11:07 pm

Avatar

hey i need to get a interview witrh a professional manga artist… can anyone help me ???

(its 4 school) hehehe
ty ty
email me!!!

7 | Mareina

November 18th, 2008 at 9:55 pm

Avatar

So do I. I’m writing a manga for my high school senior project, and one of the requirements is to conduct an interview. All the mangaka I know live in Japan ;-;

If you know someone working in this field, could you email me as well? :D (lol, this column’s old…worth a try!)

Comment Form

The Bruce Timm Gallery

  • Bruce Timm Gallery
  • Bruce Timm Gallery
  • Bruce Timm Gallery
  • Bruce Timm Gallery