02 Feb, 2010

not simple

By: Ken Haley

Written by Natsume Ono
Viz, 320 pp.
Rating: T+ (Older Teens)

I first became acquainted with Natsume Ono’s work thanks to the serialization of the quirky and idiosyncratic samurai drama, House of Five Leaves on SigIKKI. It’s a series I’m rather keen on, so of course when I found out that not simple would be getting a US release I was eager to give it a look. After having read the book, I’m not sure if I should have been quite so eager.

not simple is the life story of Ian, a young man from Australia with a rather complicated past. His tale plays out in a vaguely disjointed manner, with the ending being presented first and the rest of the volume consisting of the various events of Ian’s life leading up to first chapter. Unfortunately, his tale is one hell of a downer, consisting of atrocity after atrocity being heaped upon him from a young age, right on through to this death. If there was ever an example of someone being dealt a raw deal by fate, Ian’s it. Estranged from his family, desperately searching for his sister, he wanders to the world with a perpetual smile and a personality and innocence that screams stunted emotional growth.

He’s not the only broken character in the book, though; just about every character you meet is screwed up in some form or another. The abusive and drunken mother, the distant and apathetic father… even the eventual friend he makes in an up-and-coming author seems to try and keep Ian at an emotional arm’s length while watching the events of the opening chapter unfold in a disturbingly cold and uncaring manner. Just about everyone comes across as either horribly selfish or abusive with Ian being the only exception, though he instead comes across as so horribly broken that I just kept wishing someone would put him into therapy.

Thankfully, Natsume Ono’s art fits this story to a T. Broken, awkward and distorted-looking characters make their way across the page and seem tailor-made to give the story a disjointed, half-remembered feel. The faces of the various characters are nearly all alike, simply furthering the idea that this is all some kind of barely remembered nightmare or childhood memory. The focus on the large and vaguely unnatural eyes helps highlight each character’s emotional hook—Ian’s wide-eyed innocence; the bitter, jaded gaze of his mother; or the uncaring, almost mocking eyes of his father. If there’s one glowing aspect to this book, it’s Ono’s wonderfully awkward artwork.

This is a fairly grim read, full of rather unlikable characters being horrible and apathetic towards each other. The few characters who aren’t jerks aren’t featured enough to really save this from being bleak as hell. While Ono’s artwork is lovely to look at, it just isn’t enough to save it for me. So, in the end, not simple was a nicely drawn, but rather disappointing and depressing read.

not simple is available now.

Review copy provided by the publisher.

10 Responses to "not simple"

1 | Michelle Smith

February 2nd, 2010 at 8:26 am

Avatar

I don’t disagree that not simple is “bleak as hell,” but I think I liked it more than you did *for* that reason. I weary of happy endings, so if Ian had triumphed over all of his obstacles somehow I probably would’ve felt dissatisfied.

2 | Ken Haley

February 2nd, 2010 at 4:29 pm

Avatar

Well, I don’t really mind downer endings at all, but I personally felt this was just a bit much. It’s just horrible thing after horrible thing, and one unlikeable character after another too. I bet if it had a second volume, Ian would have gotten a puppy that would have been run over in front him.

3 | Herron

February 2nd, 2010 at 11:03 pm

Avatar

I was about to pick this up based on the art style(I really liked it). But then it seemed… boring. Like sad to be sad. I put it on the backlist, but now I might just pass.

4 | Michelle Smith

February 3rd, 2010 at 12:19 am

Avatar

I must admit I laughed at the puppy thing, horrible notion that it is.

5 | Jorge Santiago

February 10th, 2010 at 3:02 am

Avatar

I read this book because I’m a fan of Ristorante Paradiso, another Ono’s works that is coming out soon. I really enjoyed it, and its probably one of the best manga I’ve read in a while. I don’t think a story like this which is focused on bad things happening means it’s a depressing read. I find that Ian’s constant search for his sister or to follow his goal to be a runner, and his sister’s attempts to make things right with her mother are all examples of a the hidden theme to this book that even when life is bad or things continuously pop up to make life miserable, its not a reason to become a festering emo sore that never gets over it. The author friend as well, even though he’s watching this all from an outside perspective, I think it’s fairly obvious that he does care about Ian, and he does want him to be happy.
I think it is a sad book overall, but I don’t really think it should be a negative aspect on it. On the other hand, I wish more bittersweet stories like this be made. We have no shortage of stuff with stock happy endings.

6 | Michelle Smith

February 10th, 2010 at 7:37 am

Avatar

Jorge, I love the phrase “festering emo sore.” :)

I also completely agree with your final two sentences. There are series I want to end happily, of course, but sometimes I do wish for something more bittersweet. Manga used to be known for that sort of thing “back in the day,” but now happy endings are more the norm. I wonder if this is an influence from Western culture.

7 | Katherine Dacey

February 15th, 2010 at 9:46 am

Avatar

It’s a relief to see that someone else found not simple to be a kind of medieval martyr play. There’s a big difference between showing how suffering transforms a character and simply subjecting character to pain; Ian remains so hopelessly naive and simple (contrary to what Jim says about him) throughout the book that his degradation is pretty hard to watch.

As for a happy ending, no, I didn’t want one. I did hope, however, that Ian would show some signs of awareness, transformation, development… anything that indicated that he’d become a little stronger and more worldly as a result of his odyssey. File it under Not for Me, Either.

8 | Claire Elise

March 4th, 2010 at 9:16 pm

Avatar

I thought it was brilliant. I had never head of Natsume Ono before this; I simply grabbed it off the bookshelf and began reading. The first chapter had me hooked and I immediately lent it to all my friends. Now, every time I see a “homeless man” on the streets, I wonder what kind of background he has.
Just because it’s a depressing story doesn’t mean it shouldn’t be read. I’ve had the chance to know people whose lives are very similar to this… and it’s just great to get to see another perspective on life.
VERY satisfying read. <3 I adored it.

9 | Michelle Smith

March 5th, 2010 at 8:17 am

Avatar

I think this is just one of those titles that’s going to appeal to some and not to others. :)

You might know already, but just in case you don’t… Ristorante Paradiso, another one-shot by Natsume Ono, is being released this month (review coming soon!). And the sequel series, Gente, will be out in July.

10 | Ken Haley

March 5th, 2010 at 5:52 pm

Avatar

@Michelle Agreed!

And thank you everyone for the feedback. I haven’t said anything because I’m not sure what else I have to say about the material that I didn’t really mention in the original review. I do appreciate it though.

Tags