23 Apr, 2010

Alice in the Country of Hearts, Vols. 1-2

By: Connie C.

Story by QuinRose, Art by Soumei Hoshino
Published by TOKYOPOP
Rating: OT (16+)

Everyone knows and loves the story of Alice in Wonderland: a girl is taken to magical place by white rabbit and runs into all sorts of strange creatures in a set order before waking up and finding it was all a dream. After a blatant reference to a character reading the original book, Alice falls asleep and is sucked into a “game” that vaguely resembles the usual Wonderland. Neither Alice nor the reader has any idea what is going on, but all the traditional characters are replaced with hot bishounen that all love Alice. But the story goes deeper than that, and Alice finds herself becoming more and more involved with whatever game the white rabbit (Peter White) has forced her into…

I’ll admit, I set out thinking I wouldn’t enjoy this series much. I do like to read different interpretations of Alice in Wonderland, but I think it’s an overused story idea, and rarely do the adaptations do anything interesting. But Alice in the Country of Hearts is different. It starts as an offbeat retelling, but it becomes apparent very quickly that the story is way more out there than even the original set out to be, and that there’s a method to the characters’ madness, and maybe even one or two people that know what’s going on.

The interesting thing about this series is that it’s entirely driven by its Wonderland setting. As of volume two, the “game” Alice is being forced into still hasn’t been explained, and the characters are still speaking in too many riddles and have only vaguely defined personalities. The Wonderland is divided into three areas (the Hatter’s mansion, the Queen of Hearts’ castle, and Gowland’s amusement park), and in the middle of all these are the clockmaker’s tower, where Alice stays with a man named Julius. Frequently, the setting and the time of day will change as characters or events will drive Alice from one place to another and into a different bizarre situation, but one that usually sheds just a little more light on the way the Wonderland works and what the meaning of Alice being there is. Notably, Alice is the only character that’s not “in” on whatever’s going on. Also notable is the fact that Alice is a strong character that frequently leaves situations calmly and with the upper hand, something that’s very different from the norm.

Wonderland’s a violent place, and there are a lot of gunfights since all the characters are in love with Alice. Far from the usual shojo heroine obsession, nobody has exhibited an ounce of romantic tendencies, and their “love” is more a decision they make that causes them to fight amongst themselves. Which they do anyway, since each area of Wonderland is at constant war with one another. Violence and death are the strangest things of all, since no characters seem to think anything of it. The strange mechanics of death are explained in volume two.

On one hand, it’s a little frustrating to not quite know where the story is going, especially after two volumes, but on the other, the setting is so quirky and interesting that I hardly minded. Plenty of hints about the plot are dropped, but nothing is connecting as of yet. This is such a weird series, it’s hard not to get drawn in once you get started. I was suspicious at first because of the theme and because Wonderland was stocked with boys that love Alice, but there’s really a lot more to it than that, and I’m very much looking forward to more volumes of the series.

Volumes one and two of Alice in the Country of Hearts are available now.

Review copies provided by the publisher.

4 Responses to "Alice in the Country of Hearts, Vols. 1-2"

1 | USAhime

April 23rd, 2010 at 5:20 am

Avatar

I was just wondering if I could join your reviewing team! lol, I love all the reviews you have on different manga, but I think I can contribute as a younger generation reader and as a reader of some of the recent and quirky manga. Hope you have a spot open! (:

2 | Michelle Smith

April 23rd, 2010 at 10:28 am

Avatar

Not just at the moment, alas. My advice is if you want to review manga, start up a blog and do it! :) There are a few places that will link to you if you let them know you exist, which will get you noticed. Good luck!

3 | USAhime

April 23rd, 2010 at 12:50 pm

Avatar

thanks! tell me if a spot ever opens…

4 | Jan

April 24th, 2010 at 8:58 am

Avatar

“I wanted to hate this but I just couldn’t” seems to be just about every critic’s reaction to this series! I know when I opened the first volume I expected to be totally put off by squicky harem stuff and tired Wonderland references, but after I finished it, I went right out and picked up the second. The series definitely has some issues, but I was pleasantly surprised. :)

Tags