17 Dec, 2008

Off Topic: Manga for Archie Lovers?

By: Erin Finnegan

This is is a little off topic for Manga Recon, so much so that I don’t have a category for it. I am also posting off our regular schedule – there are big changes afoot here, but I can’t say what yet.

My fiancé and fellow Ninja Consultant Noah is getting manga for all of his  coworkers for Christmas. So far, he’s giving Nausicaa, Gon, Suppli, Whistle, Azumanga Daioh and the untranslated Golden Rough (it’s about golf) to age and demographic appropriate coworkers and their kids.

Noah has one coworker whose experience with comics is limited to Archie. Unfortunately, the only experience I have with Archie is Bazooka Joe comic strips on bubblegum wrappers, which doesn’t tell me much about why people like Archie comics (bad puns?). All I remember from the Archie cartoons is the theme song.

My question to you, dear readers and the greater manga blogosphere, is this: What manga or American graphic novels do you recommend for Archie readers? (This particular reader is a female in her 40’s.)

I once learned at an ICv2 conference that Archie is America’s best selling comic, thanks to it’s availability in grocery store checkout aisles. Perhaps Milton Griepp can correct me if I’m wrong, but only Shonen Jump and Naruto come close to reaching Archie’s sales numbers, thanks to their availability in Walmart.

On a sidenote: When I was a high school girl in the 1990s, I began reading Sandman comics. I asked for a bunch of Sandman graphic novels for Christmas one year, which my mom dutifully purchased. She stuck a bunch of Betty and Veronica comics inside each volume as a joke. I never read them.

6 Responses to "Off Topic: Manga for Archie Lovers?"

1 | Anna

December 17th, 2008 at 11:24 pm

Avatar

There’s the Oni Press series Blue Monday, which really captures the feeling of teen romantic comedy movies. The art style is manga influenced but I think would be very accessible for Archie readers.

2 | Erin Finnegan

December 18th, 2008 at 12:14 pm

Avatar

@Anna That’s a good call – I love Blue Monday!

3 | Scott

December 19th, 2008 at 7:54 pm

Avatar

I’ve read a fair bit of Archie ‘in my day’ … well, at my Grandmother’s house. What makes it fun is the gag-a-day deal. In manga terms, it’s like an entire series made of those gag pages in the back of most manga volumes.

I don’t know enough manga to suggest ones that would feature more of that, though … I don’t think I’ve ever read a teen/romantic/comedy manga through!

4 | rose

December 19th, 2008 at 10:54 pm

Avatar

Archie comics were very precious and not harsh. They had a Happy Days feel to them. The humor was sitcom style, lesson learned humor, with wacky shenanigans.

I read a LOT of Archie comics. Let me see if I can recall some good gags.
-Betty is crying, her mom asks why, she tells her Archie has written her a wonderful love letter, mom is confused. punchline: it is a carbon copy.

-veronica’s fancy cars keep getting stolen, and eventually she just ends up putting a trashy car onto the fast motor and chassis, because its the quality of the driving, and not the appearance, that she has learned to value.

-sabrina (the teenage witch–yes! she’s one of the archies) wants to go out, and her aunt gives her advice, one of which is that if she breaks a leg, not to go running to her.

-josie and the pussycats, with the schemeing alexa always trying to steal josie’s boyfriend, were part of the archies.

I wish I knew more about manga to recommend something. Maybe this will give you more insights? I just think something with situational humor that is not sexy, and has a really solid story will be ideal. maybe something Korean, so it doesn’t have to be read ‘backwards’?

5 | Oliver

December 22nd, 2008 at 11:20 am

Avatar

I would recommend the Archie manga series graphic novel, Sabrina the Teenage Witch. It collects the first four issues of the Sabrina comics when Sabrina’s look was changed to manga style (Archie’s attempt at appealing to the new manga generation). She’ll like it because it’s from Archie, and it’s done manga style so it won’t take her too far out of her comfort zone.

My first ever manga was Ranma 1/2 which was recommended to me at a comic store, and I enjoyed it (however, it has a slight bit of full-frontal nudity). It is also flipped so that your friend won’t be totally thrown off by it.

Otherwise, I would recommend a drama like Emma from CMX and a comedy like Nodame Cantabile from Del Rey which are not typical manga, and they would appeal more to an Archie lover. Either series seems like a best bet.

6 | Peter S

December 29th, 2008 at 5:29 pm

Avatar

On the constant chasing after the opposite sex, love triangles, etc, maybe “School Rumble” would be a good choice. And “Love Com,” since Risa and her friends change clothing styles faster then Betty and Veronica.

Tags