
Heck, I don’t know what we’re calling it. The Dark Knight 2? Batman Still Forever? Nolan’s Folly? In any case, there’s a rumor that’s got the net all hot and bothered, suggesting that Aaron Eckhart might return as Two-Face in Nolan’s third go around in Gotham. It all stems back to this quote, once again originating from MTV’s Splash Page:
“I think Harvey — if he’s not dead — is in a serious coma,” stated Eckhart, “and I’m not sure he’s coming out. They might pull the plug on him.”
Come on guys, this is an easy one. Watch the clip, and ignore the “knowing laugh” comment… Eckhart is making a joke. The interviewer prompts him with a question, he laughs, and says the above quote, which is clearly a joke. A joke, I might add, that in no way indicates Dent is still alive. If anything, it furthers confirms he is dead as a doornail.
Now for those of you who are skeptical about the “knowing laugh” comment… This is Eckhart keeping things open. Of course, he’d love to come back for another film. If he says he’s 100% dead, he doesn’t get more press. If he keeps things enigmatic, the press picks it up (as they have), and film execs hear how (potentially) excited fan-boys are for him to return, which means they pressure Chris Nolan, which means Eckhart has a better than 0% chance to be in the new movie.
Christopher Nolan doesn’t know what happens in the next movie. David Goyer doesn’t know. Warner Brothers doesn’t know. And Aaron Eckhart certainly doesn’t know.
Now, that out of the way, I want to add one more thing before we go: it didn’t occur to me, on first viewing of The Dark Knight, that Harvey was dead at all. It seemed obvious that he had fallen, been knocked unconscious, and then Gordon and Batman pretended he was dead, so he could keep on going being Gotham’s White Knight. This seemed obvious, as:
1) There was the whole scene with Eric Roberts showing how a fall from heights won’t necessarily kill you. Harvey fell from about the same height.
2) Previously, Harvey, Gordon, and Batman were involved in an extensive cover up pretending someone was dead.
I just assumed the stored him somewhere deep in Arkham, and he would be back to terrorize some more.
So it wasn’t until later, when I heard that both the novel, and the film script state that Two-Face was dead, that it occurred to me there was even a possibility he was not alive. Having that out in the ether (in particular, the novel) seems to suggest that my previous suppositions are unlikely, but who knows? Sarah Tancredi* came back from a severed head, so anything is possible.
*Where my “Prison Break” fans at?