1 | poep

August 26th, 2006 at 4:42 am

how can perfection be emma frost’s jonger self?? it makes no sense i’d expected her to be martha or someone whole new but this

2 | Jinx

August 26th, 2006 at 11:01 am

I’m sure everything will be explained…who knows, maybe its all a mind game that “Perfection” is playing on Kitty; using Kitty’s “first face of evil” as a tactic against her. I hope Joss doesn’t use that “doppleganger or clone” trick!

3 | Jon Haehnle

August 26th, 2006 at 11:24 am

i second that, jinx. i think whoever it is, they are the new white queen, they just aren’t emma frost — that’s just them messing with kitty’s head

4 | edcurb

August 26th, 2006 at 2:15 pm

what if the emma weve seen all along has been really jean grey… maybe she became emma when she saw that scott needed to be more than he was. just maybe jean as emma could do more to help those around her if she wasnt constrained by being who they all thought she was. just an idea.

5 | poep

August 28th, 2006 at 6:24 am

if the just mess with kates mind how is the real emma (phased by kate undergroud) gonna survive

i also hope the don’t use the clone doppleganger trick it has been used to much

who do you prefer emma or jean??

and who do you thing is a more powerfull telepath emma or rachel (my favorite).
and is rachel an omega level mutant like her mom jean or not, she has a phoenix emblem on her eye so id would make sense

last question jean and psylock switched powers remember. jean teke in exchanche for shadow teleporting and psylocks telepathy (not omega level)
now psylock is alive again and with jeans teke she should also be an omega because jean was and she has jeans powers ..it makes sense. And rachel on the otherhand also has a shadow form so she should be able to teleport true shadows right???

6 | poep

August 28th, 2006 at 6:44 am

oooh a other question a quess you all herd about phoenix endsong’s sequel warsong don’t it borher you that every body gets the force exept the one that got it ages long rachel jean okay kid omega ….OK but the three in one OR emma noo please don’t make her a omega level while she is an alfa dont make het a jean clone because in endsong and in warsong previews we see her as a phoenix host burning scott with some odd kind of teke or pyrokinesis and even rachel (with kurtt collosus and kitty) and and the are thinking about making emma a telekinetic for good NNNOOOOOO she so much coler than jean don’t destroy it and make her a jeanwannebe

7 | John E. Baumgartner

August 30th, 2006 at 9:46 am

that fight scene between Kitty and Emma was awesome. Kitty totally kicked her ass!

8 | dudlyl

August 31st, 2006 at 6:10 pm

Man aren’t we kind of tired of this mess yet??!!!
I stopped buying Astonishing after the first six issues.
Same old, same old Phonix is dead than she isn’t, ProfessorX is either dead, depowered or can’t walk.
Pysclops is confused, Wolverine is tall one second than short another the stories take to long before getting to the action and the ending is such a fing let down.
Oh and the artwork…………

9 | Erios

September 2nd, 2006 at 4:56 pm

The fight scene between Kitty and Emma was completely illogical and inaccurate. Let me explain: Emma has a reputation for being one of the most intelligent X-Men around with an eye for strategy. That being said, her behavior in the fight was completely out of character and borderline ridiculous.

First off, why would Emma stand idly in front of Kitty’s hiding place, taunting her like an idiot when she’s fully aware of Kitty’s ability to phase through objects? Emma is smarter than that. Furthermore, if she did telepathically locate Kitty, again why stand there taunting her when she could tap into her mind and fry her alive?

Also, Emma lets Kitty get four solid hits before transforming to diamond form. Why on earth did it take her so long? Her transformation is instantaneous, though for some reason Emma allows herself to get hit multiple times before activating it. Again, not smart, not Emma.

Lastly, when she finally does activate diamond form and Kitty is injured from kicking her, the first thing she does is jump on top of her. Why?! Why would Emma try to physically hurt Kitty when she knows she’s incapable of being hurt physically? Why wouldn’t she just blast her with a mental bolt?

The answer: obviously, Perfection wanted her to get taken out by Kitty. It was part of the plan all along. Perfection later tells Emma, “Don’t worry, you did fine,” indicating her abysmal performance in their fight was part of the plan all along. So, in reality,

Emma pwns Kitty.